Safety recordkeeping is more than just the OSHA Log. Records of inspections, training, audits, corrections and other safety activities can help you in the event of an OSHA inspection. Additionally, a good safety recordkeeping system of using these safety forms will allow you to track changes and trends which is essential in reducing workplace accidents, injuries and illnesses.
Measuring the results of workplace safety and health changes benefits employers and employees because both gain confidence that the change results in a safer workplace. Since most changes occur by trial and error or in stages, information about the effectiveness of each stage is naturally helpful to the process. These changes often result in increased productivity and demonstrate that employee safety and health can be a good investment. Employees must be involved throughout the selection of safety changes and their measurement.
Evaluations are best done by a team. When forming a team, keep in mind that workers are often the best source of information about the workplace.
Wherever possible, the team should include people who are
• affected by the safety and health change,
• responsible for implementing and maintaining the change, and/or
• involved in future decisions about changes.
The team should start by defining the problem as clearly as possible. The more specifically that the problem is defined, the better that a solution can be designed to fit, and the easier it is to test the solution. Brainstorm a solution for the problem and one or two ways to measure the effectiveness of the change. Using more than one way to measure the change will increase your confidence in the results.
Collect accurate data on workplace safety and health. Consider collecting three kinds of data: conditions before the change, information about how the change was put in place, and what happened after the change was made. Good records of how the change was made will help if you want to do it again because they tell you what happened. Data on the outcome will tell you whether to bother doing it again.
How, how often, and when should you collect data?
One way is to measure an outcome (like employee injuries) before and after the change. Typically, injuries are infrequent occurrences; therefore, you may need to collect data for quite awhile before and afterwards to make sure that any changes you detect are real. On the other hand, if you are measuring changes in employee knowledge and attitudes after a training session, you may not need to measure for as long a period of time. You may measure immediately before the training, right after the training, and then one or two more times 3 months to 1 year after the training.
Another model for gathering information is to arrange the change so that it does not affect everyone in the operation at one time. By introducing the change to several different groups over a period of several months or a year, you can get a better idea of effectiveness. Simply measure all the groups (those who receive the change immediately and those who receive it later) at regular intervals as you gradually introduce the change to the selected groups. This takes more effort, but it gives you added confidence that any detected effects are from the change and not some other event.
• Expected outcomes – what will happen as a result of the safety and health change? Whatever you expect – reduced injuries or absenteeism, increased productivity, -- measure those things.
• Nature of the safety and health change – for example, if the change is plant exhaust ventilation, then you may want to measure air quality before and after. If the change is increased rest breaks for employees, then you may want to measure productivity. If the change is new training, then you may want to look for performance indicators or success/failure rates.
• Opportunity – think of measurements that are practical. Remember that someone or something has to collect and analyze the measurements you choose.
Here are some simple ways of collecting data. If you use more than one of these methods to measure each change, you will be more certain of the results.
Here are some simple ways of collecting data. If you use more than one of these methods to measure each change, you will be more certain of the results.
• Several types of records can provide data on the effectiveness of safety and health changes.
Useful data include the following:
• Injury frequency and rates
• Workers compensation costs
• Lost workdays and absenteeism due to work-related injuries
• Profit and loss
• Air sampling data, noise readings
• Production errors or waste
• Cost of respiratory equipment or ear protection
Records should be checked for completeness and accuracy before they are used.
◦ Surveys are useful for determining workers’ perceptions both before and after a change:
• What is working well?
• What is working poorly?
• Where in the work process are there delays in production?
• Where can quality be improved?
• What procedures place workers at risk of illness or injury?
• What changes can be made to correct existing problems?
• Is the change effective?
• How has the workplace been changed?
• Are things better or worse?
• How could the change be improved?
You can also use surveys to measure knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors. Write the survey in such a way that all those who read or hear it will understand the questions. Test the survey with a sample of workers before using it to find out whether the questions are understood as you intend. Surveys can be distributed in a number of ways: in person, with paychecks, by mail, e-mail, Internet, or a combination of methods. Follow-ups are usually necessary to increase participation and get the completed forms back.
It is always best to encourage the participation of your entire workforce in a survey. Often surveys lead to planned change and survey participants are more likely to feel a sense of ownership in the change. However, if you cannot afford to survey everyone in a very large workplace, select a sample that represents all important groups such as departments within a hospital or plant, and be sure to include all the groups that are anticipated to be included in the workplace change.
It is very important to establish a system that assures the confidentiality of each person's responses, including both the collection and the reporting of the survey data, i.e., anonymous surveys and results. This can go a long way toward encouraging employees to provide honest feedback on the survey.
◦ Interviews are one-on-one, face-to-face conversations. In these conversations, the interviewer(s) asks the same set of questions to a number of people, but talking to only one person at a time. Interviews require more time and resources than surveys, but provide more detailed information. Record interviews so that statements can be accurately reviewed and analyzed. Since interviews usually involve fewer people than surveys, you should interview a range of people who represent all the important groups associated with the change. One drawback to interviews is that the data can be challenging to analyze because it may be quite detailed or because there may be extra material that is not important to the evaluation.
◦ Focus groups involve gathering information and opinions that are “focused” on one subject from a small group of people (about 8 to 10 per group). These group discussions often provide insights that might not emerge in interviews. Focus groups can be used in all stages of making a safety and health change — from planning to determining effectiveness. You may want to recruit participants with similar characteristics (such as job classification) since group discussions often thrive on common experience. Hold separate group discussions when you want to solicit opinions from supervisors and the employees they supervise. Assuring the confidentiality of such discussions is essential.
Below are tips for planning and conducting a focus group:
• Develop a list of discussion topics ahead of time.
• Determine the amount of time to be spent on each topic. (Good discussions usually require about 1 ½ – 2 hours. )
• Design questions in such a way that they encourage discussion. (Don’t ask questions that get short answers like “yes” or “true.”)
• Start the session with an “ice breaker” that gets everyone to talk. Make sure that everyone knows that they are expected to contribute.
• Have an experienced note taker attend. If you can get all participants’ permission, record the session on audio or video tape.
• Afterward, review the tape or transcript and summarize major points. If a transcript is prepared, be sure to substitute fictional names for the names of actual participants.
• Sample of people and time periods.
• Record your observations. This may involve watching people in person and recording their actions on a checklist. It could also involve recording people on video tape and then categorizing their actions later with the checklist.
• Whether you record people on tape or not, explain what you’re doing and why, and get their permission before you observe. Even though they know you’re watching, most people will quickly forget about it. Remember that the presence of an observer may affect what people do.
◦ Some safety and health changes are designed to improve the physical work environment. Two examples are noise baffles around loud equipment and extra ventilation to remove contaminants. Environmental measures can help determine whether these changes are effective. Environmental measures include air sampling and noise monitoring. This type of data gathering may require people with special equipment and training, but the data they can collect may help pinpoint the value of the change.
• Allow team members to interpret findings independently.
• Compare members’ findings with the goals set by the team.
• Arrive at conclusions about the change on the basis of the findings.
• Summarize the results in such a way that everyone involved understands them.
After the initial analysis is complete, you may want to continue collecting data about the change. These data can serve as baseline measures for future interventions. They are also useful for determining the long-term impact of the change.
First, share your results with those affected by the change. The more you tell them about what you did and what you found, the more they will support your conclusions and your future efforts to evaluate safety and health changes in the workplace. A good way to start the feedback process is to hold work-group meetings to present the results. Don't worry about drawing conclusions from the results, just start with the basic findings. This approach will permit everyone to begin thinking about what the results suggest. You could also post the results in worker areas like break rooms, locker rooms, and cafeterias.
During the data analysis and results steps, be careful to maintain confidentiality. Breeches in confidentiality can affect your credibility. Do not report results in such a way that individual responses can be identified. This is especially important where there are workgroups of 3-6 people. In such circumstances, it may be necessary to report results for several workgroups, combined.
What Does It All Mean?
Making changes in the workplace is not easy. Take time to think about how you are going to evaluate your changes. Thinking through your options will provide you with the information necessary for making better decisions in the long run.
Evaluation can be very complicated or it can be relatively simple. Although the simplest methods may be seem less "scientific," they can still give you good information for making some important decisions. After a simple evaluation, you can decide to expand the intervention to other work groups in your company, or consider making additional changes.
Improving worker safety and health, as well as increasing productivity, is a continual process of:
problem identification ->
determination of a solution ->
solution implementation ->
analysis and discussion of results ->
judgments and conclusions ->
new problem identification.
Your organization may benefit from evaluations done by others and vice versa. Share your evaluation results with local and national trade associations and labor unions. Some international organizations are developing solutions databases to make such information available worldwide.
Forms & Documents
|Accident Report Form|
|Aerial Scissor Lift Inspection Form|
|Air Sample Survey|
|Alternate Duty Selection Guide Form|
|Annual Authorized Employee Lockout Tagout Certification Form|
|Assignment Of Ergonomic Program Coordinator Ergonomics Form|
|Bloodborne Pathogens Exposure And Treatment Notification Form|
|Bloodborne Pathogens Exposure Report Form|
|Bloodborne Pathogens Notice Of HBV Vaccination Form|
|Bloodborne Pathogens Training Certificate Form|
|Chemical Inventory List Form|
|Company Policy Review Ergonomics Form|
|Competent Person Evaluation Form|
|Confined Space Attendant Duties Form|
|Confined Space Entry Log Form|
|Confined Space Logic Chart Form|
|Confined Space Permit Form|
|Confined Space Training Certification Form|
|Contractor Safety Evaluation Form|
|Contractor Work Permit Form|
|Crane Hand Signals Form|
|Crane Operator License Form|
|Daily Excavation Inspection Form|
|EPA Oil Spill And Chem Release Form|
|EPA Storm Water Sampling Form|
|Electrical Safety Inspection Form|
|Electrical Training Certificate Form|
|Electrical Work Permit Form|
|Emergency Ex Chart|
|Emergency Incident Forms Air Operations Summary Worksheet|
|Emergency Incident Forms Assignment List|
|Emergency Incident Forms Check In List|
|Emergency Incident Forms Demobilization Checkout|
|Emergency Incident Forms Incident Action Plan Analysis Instruction|
|Emergency Incident Forms Incident Action Plan Analysis|
|Emergency Incident Forms Incident Briefing|
|Emergency Incident Forms Incident Status Summary|
|Emergency Incident Forms Medical Plan|
|Emergency Incident Forms Message Blank|
|Emergency Incident Forms Operational Planning Sheet|
|Emergency Incident Forms Organization Assignment List|
|Emergency Incident Forms Radio Comm Plan|
|Emergency Incident Forms Radio Frequency Assignement|
|Emergency Incident Forms Resource Status Card Aircraft|
|Emergency Incident Forms Resource Status Card Crew|
|Emergency Incident Forms Resource Status Card Heavy Equipment|
|Emergency Incident Forms Resource Status Card Helio|
|Emergency Incident Forms Response Objectives|
|Emergency Incident Forms Site Safety And Control|
|Emergency Incident Forms Status Change Card|
|Emergency Incident Forms Support Vehicle Inventory|
|Emergency Incident Forms Unit Log|
|Emergency Vulnerability Chart|
|Employee Chemical Exposure Report Form|
|Energized Electrical Work Permit Form|
|Environmental Release And Corrective Actions Form|
|Equipment Issue Log Ergonomics Form|
|Ergonomics Form Trg Sup|
|Event Crowd Management Form|
|Explosive Blasting Permit Form|
|Fire Drill Evaluation Form|
|Fleet Driver Haz Placards|
|Fleet Driver Pre Trip|
|Fleet Driver Veh Ws Use|
|Floor Grating Removal Permit Form|
|Floor Grating Removal Procedure Form|
|Forklift Operator Required Training Form|
|Forklift Pit Operator Certificate Form|
|Hazard Assessment Worksheet Form|
|Hazard Assessment Worksheet PPE Form|
|Hazard Control Log Ergonomics Form|
|Hazard Control Worksheet Form|
|Hazard Report Form|
|Hazard Surveillance Form|
|Hazcom JSA Job Safety Task Steps Form|
|Hazcom Training Certificate Form|
|Hearing Loss Prevention Program Form|
|Hot Work Permit Form|
|Hydro Blast Level 01 Certification Form|
|Hydro Blast Level 02 Certification Form|
|Hydro Blast Level 03 Operator Form|
|Hydro Blast Task Assessment Form|
|Ih Noise Survey Form|
|Job Hazard Analysis Assessment Worksheet For PPE Form|
|Job Safety Analysis JSA Form|
|Lifting Analysis Explanation Ergonomics Form|
|Lifting Analysis Worksheet 02 Ergonomics Form|
|Lifting Analysis Worksheet Ergonomics Form|
|Lockout Tagout Group Form|
|Lockout Tagout Survey Form|
|Lockout Tagout Training Certificate Form|
|MSD Hazard Control Report Ergonomics Form|
|MSD Symptom Locations Ergonomics Form|
|MSD Symptom Report Ergonomics Form|
|MSD Symptom Survey Ergonomics Form|
|Manlift Monthly Checks Form|
|Manlift Weekly Checks Form|
|Mtg Safety Meeting Minutes Form|
|Near Miss Report Form|
|Nerve Conduction Motor Latency Evaluation Ergonomics Form|
|New Employee Safety Orientation Form|
|New Employee Supervisor Safety Training Form|
|OCC Health Form Alternate Duty Medical Release|
|OCC Health Form Hepatitis B Immunization|
|OCC Health Form Influenza Vaccination Record|
|OCC Health Form Medical Refferal And Work Release|
|OCC Health Form Modified Duty|
|OCC Health Form New Hire Medical Exam Status|
|OCC Health Form Return To Duty|
|OCC Health Form Treatment Record|
|PPE Assessment Certification Form|
|PSM Crit Dev Form|
|PSM Entry Permit|
|PSM Equip List Form|
|PSM Line Break Form|
|PSM Maint Schedule|
|PSM Process Dia|
|PSM Psi Info|
|PSM Trg Ori Eng|
|Recordkeeping 2004 Osha300a Summary|
|Recordkeeping 2004 Osha300log|
|Recordkeeping 2004 Osha301 Form|
|Recordkeeping 300 Log|
|Recordkeeping 300a Summary|
|Recordkeeping 301 Report|
|Recordkeeping New Osharecordkeeping Form|
|Request For Medical Firstaid Record Access Form|
|Respirator Fit Test Record Form|
|Respirator Medical Firstaid Questionnaire Form|
|Respirator Schedule Form|
|Respirator Training Certificate Form|
|Respiratory Program Administrator Form|
|SDS Material Safety Data Sheet Form|
|SDS Request Letter Form|
|Safety Event Scheduling Chart Form|
|Supplemental Report Of Injury Form|
|Suspension Trailer Inspection Form|
|Training Certificate Ergonomics Form|
|Vehicle Accident Report Analysis Worksheet Form|
|Vehicle Accident Report Form|
|Violence Incident Report Form|
|Weekly Supervisor Safety Inspection Form|
|Recordkeeping 2004 OSHA 300 1 1 04 Form|
|Recordkeeping OSHA 300 Form|
|Recordkeeping OSHA 300 Y2002|
GET INSTANT ACCESS
to THE MEMBERS LIBRARY
Safety materials created by safety professionals.
Access to the Safety Manager software.
Wide variety of safety videos and courses.
**Brand New** Safety Training Management System
Looking For HSE?
We have what you need
Free with full membership subscription
Training LMS System
Ask The Safety Consultant
Safety Equipment Deal Finder
Inside the Members Library
Cranes & Slings
Driver / Fleet Safety
Drug Free Workplace
Fire Safety & Prevention
Job Safety Analysis
Machinery & Equipment
Medical & First Aid
Off the Job Safety
Rules & Policies
Signs & Labels
Slips, Trips & Fall
Vehicle & Driver
Welding & Hot Work
Confined Space Death
Confined Space Hazards & Response
Driving & Medication
Electrical Arc Flash Hazards
Fall Protection - Tie Off
Forklift Carbon Monoxide Hazard
Forklift Tipover Accidents
Forklifts & Pedestrians
Healthcare Worker Safety
Hot Work Dangers
Lockout - Tagout
Reactive Chemical Hazards - Process
Safety For Small Business
Understanding Job Stress - for Managers
Young Worker Safety
2 Minute OSHA Safety Talks
First Aid Training
Forms & Documents
Safety Management Resources
Process Safety Management
Drug Free Workplace
Safety Manager Software
23 Module Software - Manage, Track, Schedule & OSHA Log
1. Employee Info
2. Accident Reports
3. Incident Reports
4. Lockout - Tagout
5. Corrective Actions
6. Equipment Safety
7. Confined Space
8. Hot Work Permits
9. Vehicle Accidents
10. Safety Committee
11. Industrial Hygiene
12. IR Calculator
13. Respirator Schedule
14. Protective Equipment
15. Chemical Exposure
16. Event Planner
17. Expense Tracker
18. Job Safety Analysis
19. Chemical Data
20. Training Planner
22. Process Safety
23. Chemical Labels
Safety References & Graphics
New Safety Training System